TY - JOUR
T1 - Retraction
T2 - On the enzymatic activity of catalase: An iron L-edge X-ray absorption study of the active centre (Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics (2010) 12 (4827-4832) DOI: 10.1039/b924245g)
AU - Bergmann, Nora
AU - Bonhommeau, Sébastien
AU - Lange, Kathrin M.
AU - Greil, Stefanie M.
AU - Eisebitt, Stefan
AU - De Groot, Frank
AU - Chergui, Majed
AU - Aziz, Emad F.
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© the Owner Societies 2018.
PY - 2018
Y1 - 2018
N2 - We the named authors, hereby wholly retract this Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics article due to inconsistencies in the experimental X-ray absorption spectrum of met-haemoglobin (met-Hb) in Fig. 1a of this PCCP paper. As part of an investigation carried out on behalf of Helmholtz-Zentrum fur Materialien und Energie GmbH it was concluded that improper data treatment had occurred in this instance. Fig. 1a should be a reproduction of the X-ray absorption spectrum published in Fig. 1a of ref. 1, as indicated in the main text. However, the L3/L2 intensity ratios are different and the spectral changes in the PCCP paper contain an abrupt intensity jump at 713 eV. The spectrum published in our PCCP paper is not consistent with backups of raw data from the beamline computer and it was thus modified while no specific data treatment is mentioned. In addition, we note that in ref. 1, the sample was described as a 3 mM aqueous solution of "hemoglobin" (Hb) in the main text, while in the supplemental information it was pointed out that "since native Hb is readily oxidized in air, the preparation is predominantly methemoglobine (>98%)". The spectrum presented in Fig. 1a of our PCCP paper was referred to as met-Hb, with no description of the preparation of the solution beyond referencing to ref. 1. Signed: Nora Bergmann, Sebastien Bonhommeau, Kathrin M. Lange, Stefanie M. Greil, Stefan Eisebitt, Frank de Groot, Majed Chergui and Emad F. Aziz, 22nd May 2018. Retraction endorsed by Katie Lim, Executive Editor, Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics.
AB - We the named authors, hereby wholly retract this Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics article due to inconsistencies in the experimental X-ray absorption spectrum of met-haemoglobin (met-Hb) in Fig. 1a of this PCCP paper. As part of an investigation carried out on behalf of Helmholtz-Zentrum fur Materialien und Energie GmbH it was concluded that improper data treatment had occurred in this instance. Fig. 1a should be a reproduction of the X-ray absorption spectrum published in Fig. 1a of ref. 1, as indicated in the main text. However, the L3/L2 intensity ratios are different and the spectral changes in the PCCP paper contain an abrupt intensity jump at 713 eV. The spectrum published in our PCCP paper is not consistent with backups of raw data from the beamline computer and it was thus modified while no specific data treatment is mentioned. In addition, we note that in ref. 1, the sample was described as a 3 mM aqueous solution of "hemoglobin" (Hb) in the main text, while in the supplemental information it was pointed out that "since native Hb is readily oxidized in air, the preparation is predominantly methemoglobine (>98%)". The spectrum presented in Fig. 1a of our PCCP paper was referred to as met-Hb, with no description of the preparation of the solution beyond referencing to ref. 1. Signed: Nora Bergmann, Sebastien Bonhommeau, Kathrin M. Lange, Stefanie M. Greil, Stefan Eisebitt, Frank de Groot, Majed Chergui and Emad F. Aziz, 22nd May 2018. Retraction endorsed by Katie Lim, Executive Editor, Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics.
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85048626984&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1039/c8cp91772h
DO - 10.1039/c8cp91772h
M3 - Comment/debate
C2 - 29862392
AN - SCOPUS:85048626984
SN - 1463-9076
VL - 20
SP - 16294
JO - Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics
JF - Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics
IS - 23
ER -