Post-anaesthesia pulmonary complications after use of muscle relaxants (POPULAR): A multicentre, prospective observational study

Brigitte Leva, Pierre Harlet, Prisca Feijten, Sandrine Damster, Manfred Blobner, Lars I. Eriksson, Markus Hollmann, Jennifer Hunter, Malin Jonsson Fagerlund, Eva Kirmeier, Heidrun Lewald, Claude Meistelma, Kurt Ulm, Elisabeth Dum, Theresia Von Lutterotti, Markus Köstenberger, Helene Lercher, Stefan Neuwersch, Johann Knotzer, Oskar KotzingerGudrun Gferer, Manuela Pitterle, Harald Sparr, Marc Moritz Berger, Thomas Danninger, Kristen Kopp, Cornelia Kunit, Julia Ausserer, Daniel Hoelbling, Karin Khuenl-Brady, Peter Paal, Daniel Pehboeck, Miriam Potocnik, Carine Smitz, Marcel Vercauteren, Veerle Verheyen, Guy Cammu, Zeljka Gavranovic, Branka Maldini, Tatjana Goranovic, Tino Klancir, Marko Kovacevic, Ana Markic, Branka Mazul Sunko, Visnja Nesek Adam, Morena Milic, Nataša Sojcic, Bibiana Vitkovic, Andrea Nováková, Lubomir Vecera, Hana Harazim, Martina Kosinová, Olga Smékalová, Petr Štourac, Paula Dzurnáková, Katarina Lišková, Ivana Volfová, Arash Afshari, Kim Ekelund, Andreas Elme, Juri Karjagin, Alar Sõrmus, Hardo Toim, Etienne Junke, Claude Meistelman, Bernard Allaouchiche, Emmanuel Boselli, Lionel Bouvet, Marc Danguy Des Déserts, Ba Vinh Nguyen, Gilda F.Pardey Bracho, Sandrine Saby, Grégory Bois, Matthieu Leuvrey, Cindy Mathis, Aude Moeglen, Simon Philippe, Loïc Scalco, Catherine Schmidt-Mutter, Marlène Stoerckel, Elsa Carise, Bertrand Debaene, Denis Frasca, Thomas Ernst, Andre Gottschalk, Anna Von Tiesenhausen, Henrik Rüffert, Bettina Jungwirth, Urs Foerster, Fabian Ripke, Stefan Schaller, Christiane Stäuble, Fabian Lipski, Madeleine Luippold, Winfried Roth, Korbinian Rupprecht, Florian Schmidt-Ehrenberg, Tom Philipp Zucker, Nicole Bergmann, Petra Bischoff, Ludger Mittelstädt, Johann Wallner, Hartmut Bürkle, Ulrich Göbe, Kai Kaufmann, Holger Pohl, Marie Therese Rotter, Johannes Spaeth, Steffen Wirth, Christian Zachoval, Christoph Schax, Annika Spielmann, Thomas Standl, Johanna Feggeler, Carla Bankewitz, Georg Baumgarten, Richard Ellerkmann, Tobias Fellmann, Andreas Fleischer, Ulf Günther, Vera Guttenthaler, Yvonne Hack, Andreas Hoeft, Katharina Kirchgäßner, Olja Männer, Bahareh Marchand, Marlen Schurig, Rafael Struck, Rebekka Van Zyl, Stefan Weber, Maria Wittmann, Peter Kranke, Eva Kranke, Alina Balandin, Stephanie Kraus, Christiane Kraus, Thomas Metterlein, Christina Schönberg, Christoph Unterbuchner, Markus Werkmann, Raphael Ziegleder, Dimitrios Gkinas, Eirini Oloktsidou, Konstantinos Papapostolou, Georgia Tsaousi, George Gkiokas, Matthaios Stamelos, Kassiani Theodoraki, Konstantinos Stroumpoulis, Dimitrios Valsamidis, Eleni Mavrommati, Virginia Tanou, Aikaterini Tsiftsi, George Vassilakis, Eleni Katsika, Dimitrios Korfiotis, Paschalitsa Serchan, Aikaterini Chatzimicali, Alexandra Papaioannou, Paulina Syrogianni, Chrysanthi Batistaki, Aikaterina Kyttari, Paraskevi Matsota, Donal Buggy, Martina Prchalova, Aisling Ní Eochagáin, Helen Keane, Imad Darwish, Eyad Elghouty, Arturo Toninelli, Gea Erika Bucolo, Maria Concetta Monea, Luigi Giancarlo Vicari Sottosanti, Valentina Barletti, Eleonora Bonicolini, Irene Gambino, Andrea Meli, Stefano Romagnoli, Caterina Stera, Manuela Campesato, Filomena Copeta, Ida Di Giacinto, Rita Maria Melotti, Maria Cristina Sorella, Jessica Toni, Tommaso Vecchiatini, Daniela Vissicchio, Giorgio Fullin, Alberto Grassetto, Elena Serafini, Silvia Zampieri, Giorgio Gambale, Georgia Malewski, Davide Morri, Marco Tartaglione, Stefano Ciardo, Stefania Taddei, Ruggero Massimo Corso, Antonio Gioia, Anna Maria Legrottaglie, Stefano Maitan, Salvatore Zampone, Francesca Bifulco, Marco Cascella, Arturo Cuomo, Maria MacIariello, Vincenzo Pota, Vincenzo Schiavone, Gabriele Aletti, Maria Amigoni, Francesco Butturini, Cecilia Giovannoni, Zhirajr Mokini, Antonio Pesenti, Giovanni Vitale, Martina Baiardo Redaelli, Mattia Bellandi, Alessandro Belletti, Luigi Beretta, Elena Bignami, Giuseppina Maria Casiraghi, Daniela Febres, Marcello Guarnieri, Giovanni Landoni, Livia Manfredini, Enrico Antonio Martino, Pasquale Nardelli, Laura Pasin, Omar Saleh, Anna Spada, Massimo Zambon, Alberto Zangrillo, Arcispedale Sant'Anna, Francesco Barbera, Valentina Cricca, Alessandro Orlando, Riccardo Ragazzi, Savino Spadaro, Marco Verri, Carlo Alberto Volta, Maurizio Fusari, Silvia Mescolini, Manuela Negri, Massimo Terenzoni, Gianluca Zani, Cosima Carrieri, Gerardo Montillo, Giordano Nardin, Laura Lorenzini, Luca Brazzi, Leda Floris, Corrado Liperi, Laura Pistidda, Gabriele Sales, Gilda Cinnella, F. Stefania Lombardi, Maria Rosaria Menga, Lucia Mirabella, Rocco Petta, Piero Di Mauro, Jacopo Fumagalli, Francesco Marrazzo, Concezione Tommasino, Andrea Cortegiani, Antonino Giarratano, Francesca Montalto, Santi Maurizio Raineri, Vincenzo Russotto, Marcella Brazzoni, Adelisa De Flaviis, Cristian Deana, Giorgio Della Rocca, Livia Pompei, Ilaria Toretti, Anna Vilardi, Giovanni Maria Guadagnin, Agreta Gecaj-Gashi, Medita Hashimi, Fatos Katanolli, Vilda Baliuliene, Monika Bernotaite, Diana Bilskiene, Andrius Bubliauskas, Tomas Bukauskas, Aurika Karbonskiene, Grazina Keraitiene, Andrius MacAs, Kestutis Rimaitis, Marius Rimaitis, Darius Trepenaitis, Asta Zavackiene, Aleksandar Dimitrovski, Biljana Kuzmanovska, Vanja Gievski, Aleksandar Radoeshki, Mirjana Shosholcheva, Charlotte Beurskens, Susanne Eberl, Sabrine Hemmes, Jeroen Hermanides, Henning Hermanns, Lena Koers, Fabian Kooij, Philipp Lirk, Jorinde Polderman, Benedikt Preckel, Carin Wensing, Marcus Schultz, Markus Stevens, Anna Wilhelmina Margaretha Maria Koopman-Van Gemert, Arthur Bouwman, Eric Koolen, Tim Van Der Beek, Wolfgang F. Buhre, Aliaksandr Kudrashou, Jan Uwe Schreiber, Tom Van Zundert, Hans D. De Boer, Roshane M. Hettiarachchi, Aruna Fernando, Gert Jan Scheffer, Turgay Inan, Nick Van Dasselaar, Frans Van Poorten, Bas Verdouw, Sandra Numan, Wilton A. Van Klei, Bas Van Zaane, Christa Boer, Yoni Van Duivenvoord, Rienk Van Beek, Harry Zonneveldt, Siv Hestenes, Grethe Melbybråthen, Erick Rial, Tayyba Aslam, Therese Bjønness, Espen Lindholm, Else Marie Ringvold, Elin Andersen, Live Kummen, Anders Rasmussen, Anders Rudjord, Anders Feyling, Tom Heier, Tanja Saman Siamansour, Andrzej Kanski, Malgorzata Starczewska, Miraslawa Borecka-Kedzierska, Katarzyna Gilowska, Ewa Gornik-Wlaszczuk, Rafal Kucharski, Jacek Majewski, Michal Borys, Miroslaw Czuczwar, Pawel Piwowarczyk, Beata Potrec, Elzbieta Rypulak, Justyna Sysiak, Justyna Garlak, MacIej Zukowski, Ricardo Calhau, Joana Carreteiro, Suzana Parente, Gabriela Costa, Mariana Cunha, Susana Domingues, Lucia Marinheiro, Fernando Moura, Maria Tarroso, Pedro Vasconcelos, Laila Castelo-Branco, Miriam Neves, Rita Pinto, Sofia Santos, Patricia Azevedo, Cristina Carmona, Isabel Oliveira, Teresa Branco, Manuela Casal, Filinto Correia De Barros, Simao Esteves, Leonia Ferreira, Humberto MacHado, Isabel Madeira, Catia Mascarenhas, Zelia Moreira, Manuela Pereira, Pedro Pina, Jacinta Sá, Paula Sá Couto, Pedro Antunes, José Pedro Assunção, Ana Barros, Patrick Ferreira, Carla Pereira, Vitor Pinho-Oliveira, André Rato, Sandy Ribeiro, Patrícia Rodrigues, Manuel Vico, Daniela Cernea, Alice Dragoescu, Andreea Stanculescu, Ioana Grintescu, Liliana Mirea, Daniela Ologoiu, Liviu Tiganiuc, Victoria Badarau, Iulia Cîndea, Simona Cocu, Dan Sebastian Dîrzu, Natalia Hagau, Cristina Balan, Aura Daniliuc, Victor Ioniţav, Daniela Filipescu, Alina Paunescu, Gabriela Droc, Oana Mara Stefan, Simona Vaida, Alexandra Voicu, Alexandra Marcu, Mihai Popescu, Dana Tomescu, Andrada Tudor, Roxana Badescu, Daniela Godoroja, Carmen Balescu-Arion, Alida Moise, Corina Dascalu, Ioana Grigoras, Alexandru Parfeni, Irina Ristescu, Andreea Cantor, Luminata Cimpeanu, Lucian Horhota, Daniela Bandrabur, Emoke Almasy, Victoria Barsan, Sanda Copotoiu, Janos Szederjesi, Sergey Fedorov, Svetlana Galushka, Roman Gavrilov, Konstantin Lazarev, Igor Chervjakov, Alexey Gritsan, Galina Gritsan, Oleg Korolkov, Natalya Anipchenko, Alexander Lugovoy, Alexey Ovezov, Miomir Jovic, Milan Milojevic, Jelena Sagic, Dragana Unic-Stojanovic, Vesna Dinic, Radmilo Jankovic, Nenad Savic, Teodora Bozic, Radmila Popovic, Snezana Stanisavljevic, Dejan Vukcevic, Biljana Stošic, Vojislava Neskovic, Goran Rondovic, Rade Vukovic, Simona Humplíková, Martin Michalov, Peter Mráz, Lucia Polakovicová, Ondrej Stanek, Katarína Tarabová, Aleksandar Bilic, Darja Kasnik, Janez Kompan, Jasna Uranjek, Anna Wegiel Leskiewicz, Katarina Borstnar, Bozena Gerjevic, Tomaz Ursic, Janez Dolinar, Renata Hribar, Darja Zupancic, Andriy Grynyuk, Benedik Janez, Matej Jenko, Jasmina Markovic Bozic, Katarina Marusic-Gaser, Vesna Novak-Jankovic, Alenka Spindler-Vesel, Minca Voje, Simona Vrecic-Slabe, Alexo López Alvarez, Lidia Padin Barreiro, Yvan Enrique Sanchez Sanchez, Irene Casanova, Carlos Luis Errando, Manuel Granell, Diaz Gomez, Alberto Lisi, Gisela Perez Tejero, Ana Milena Vargas Munoz, Adrian Fernández Castineira, Antonia Pérez Soto, Carlos Ferrando, Maria Luisa Garcia-Perez, Amanda Miñana, Tania Moreno, Ernesto Pastor, Esther Romero, Marina Soro, Itahísa Cabrera Díaz, Aníbal Pérez, Silvia Valldeperas Ferrer, Patricia Vidal Mitjans, María Elizabeth Agudelo Montoya, Isabel A.Becerra Cayetano, Isabel Delgado Garcia, Concepción Moro Velasco, Rosalia Navarro Perez, Paula Tardaguila Sancho, Inmaculada India, Santiago Pinol, Carmen Unzueta, Julio Belmonte Cuenca, Carlos Castro, Maria Soler Pedrola, Maria Inmaculada Valldeperas Hernandez, Begoña Ayas Montero, Aitana Lluch Oltra, Paula Perez Caballero, Adriana Calderon, Angel Callejo, Luis M. Casero, Matilde Gonzalez, Maria Guerrero Diez, Raquel Jimenez, Salah Din Kadaoui, Meta Levstek, Eloisa Lopez Lopez, Maria Martin Ayuso, Marta Novillo, Francisco Perez-Cerda, Maria Isabel Real Navacerrada, P. Agostina Vullo, Alfredo Abad Gurumeta, Jorge Baltasar Isabel, Nicolas Brogly, Fernando Gilsanz Rodriguez, Berta Herrera Hueso, Fabrizio Iannuccelli, Alejandro Suarez De La Rica, Maria Bermudez Lopez, Barbara Jimenez Gomez, Maria Lopez Rodríguez, Andrea Naveiro Pan, Jandro Pico Veloso, Mercedes Ayuso, Ricardo Moreno, Adela Benitez-Cano, Juan Fernández-Candil, Eliana López, Luis Moltó, Francisco Xavier Santiveri, Oriol Cervantes, Esther Martinez, Enrique Moret, Frederic Ródenas, Patrik Ekengren, Victoria Sem, Daniel Smole, Erik Wikström, Lars Gillberg, Anna Granstrom, Ahmed Khudhur, Anders Oldner, Anna Schening, Bjorn Åslin, Jakob Wallden, Henrik Westberg, Hanna Wallberg, Peder Andersson, Malin Rundgren, Louise Walther Sturesson, Jacob Broms, Mona Britt Divander, Callis Ewaldsson, Eva Joelsson-Alm, Christer Svensén, Borås, Anders Byttner, Kristina Bergmark, Peter Gottfridsson, Anna Molin, Ivan Blokhin, Lina Jonikaite, Egidijus Semenas, Neslihan Alkis, Özlem Selvi Can, Çigdem Güçlü, Basak Ceyda Meço, Sanem Çakar Turhan, Süheyla Karadag, Volkan Baytas, Ferim Gunenc, Volkan Hanci, Semih Kucukguclu, Bahar Kuvaki, Sule Ozbilgin, Fatma Nur Akgün, Ceren Sanli Karip, Guldem Turan, Borys Kabakov, Leonora Bowen, Victoria Frost, Mark Gordon Mac Gregor, Elizabeth Smee, Kate Blethyn, Benjamin Harris, Emma Rogers, Nimu Varsani, Andrew Wade, Sebastian Clark, Peter Knowlden, Malgorzata Lowicka, MacIej Ryszka, Alina Hua, Vinothan Loganathan, Katarzyna Mrozek, Kylie Norrie, Marcela Paola Vizcaychipi, Jagannath Haldar, Vipul Jain, Andris Klucniks, Ashley Allan, Sean Cope, Julie Furneval, Kiran Kumar Koneti, Ryszard Palugniok, Elaine Chinery, Marianne Morgan, Lajos Zsisku, Amanda Cowton, James Limb, Amir Rafi, Radhika Ramasamy, Patrick Abigail, Stuart Gallacher, Benjamin Hyams, Gary Minto, Mary Avvai, Tejal Desai, Vinayak Kumar, Helen Thornley, Fiona Linton, Sarah Moreton, Mark Pulletz, Lydia Richardson, Richard Pugh, Ramakrishnan Shobha, Stella Wright, Kira Achaibar, Heena Bidd, Nadia Blunt, Joanna Booth, Priyakam Chondhury, George Christodoudiles, John Cronin, Alexandra Dumitrescu, Ade Hafisayena, Maria Leong, Sonja Meier, Zahra Rajput, Suneil Ramessur, Emma Taylor, Brian Trethowan, Thomas Collyer, James Featherstone, Alice Moull, Caroline Abernethy, Packianathaswamy Balaji, Anna Greenwood, Kate Henderson, Ali Husnain, Ahmed Hussein, Victoria Martinson, David Pickering, Rajeskar Ramachandran, Neil Smith, Altaf Sultanpori, Gabor Debreceni, Dawn Hales, Sameer Hanna-Jumma, Gary Lau, Nathalie Rich, Sarah Bowrey, Vandana Girotra, Mary Mushambi, Andan Patil, Saif Nasr Baluch, James Heaton, Silvia Leonardi, Bernd Oliver Rose, Emily Christie, Martin Kelly, Vandana Goel, Daniel Saul, Ashok Sinha, Ahmad Chishti, Carmen Scott, David Saunders, Rhona Sinclair, Katie Allan, Tim Baker, Katrina Barber, Parveen Dhillon, Benjamin Fox, Siobhan King, Louise Oduro-Dominah, Caroline Reavley, Carmen Soto, Farooq Brohi, Prabhakar Paranthaman, Khalid Siddiqi, Jane Hunt, Guy Rousseau, Amanda Skinner, Lucia Stancombe, Sanjeev Garg, Helena Barcraft-Barnes, Julie Camsooksai, Carrie Colvin, Sarah Jenkins, Sarah Patch, Henrik Reschreiter, Lee Tbail, Keith Ritchie, Jeremy Nightingale, Aneeta Sinha, Julian Giles, Orla Harvey, Caroline Nicholas, Debbie Weller, Anil Hormis, Leigh Boxall, Katherine Curley, Laurence Helliwell, Katie Ilett, Laurie Kidd, Maria Nadolski, Alison Potter, Richard Telford, Jane Martin, Stephen Townley, James Doolan, Sam Michlig, Burra V.S. Murthy, Andrew Rushton, Deborah Scanlon, Smita Gosavi, Mehrun Zuleika, Earlene Armstrong, Jonathan Holland, Killian McCourt, Claire Montgomery, Rosalind O'Reilly, James Reid, Martin Shields, Ilana Delroy-Buelles, James Gaynor, Christian Schopflin, Davina Watson, Ben Chandler, Daniel Harper, Helen Ellis, Sumayer Sanghera, Christian Frey, Emily Adam, Pauline Bartlett, Nigel Beauchamp, Thomas Blincoe, Robert Charnock, Nicola Cox, Mark Edwards, Lesley Hawkins, Samantha Leggett, Neil McGill, Robin Wilson, Raymond McKee, Karim Mukhtar, Luke Bishop, Pawan Gupta, Carl Ilyas, Andrew Lumb, Olga Plotnikova, Roshan Rao, Rajendra Singh, Hao Ern Tan, Isobel Amey, Yolanda Baird, Anna Carter, Judith Highgate, Jordi Margalef, Michael Margarson, Sally Moore, Heather Murray, Tom Standley, Clare Allcock, Kirsty Baron, Susan Merotra, Nahla Farid, Julian Sonksen, Stephanie Bell, Heather Blaylock, Vlad Kushakovsky, Emanuel Cirstea, Uwe Franke, Louise Swan, Kirsty Davies, Jayne Edwards, John John, Julie Steen, James Craig, Emma Willett, Laura Wood, Tracy Brear, Charlotte Downes, Ryan Humphries, Susan Melbourne, David Rogerson, Stephen Sarno, Faye Moore, Sudeshkumar Muniyappa, Narendra Siddaiah, Gill Barnett, Tom Bradley, Gabrielle De Selincourt, Aiden Melia, Pauline Mercer, Jane Montgomery, Nahla Awad, Jatin Dedhia, Suganthi Joachim, Usman Razaque, Conrad Hayes, Samuel Passey, Nalwaya Pramod, Tamiselvan Rajamanickam, Siby Sebestian, Permendra Singh, Rajinikanth Sundara Rajan, Benedict Williams, Louise Duncan, Melanie Kent, Selena Sehgal, Sameer Somanath, Matthew Clayton, Dominika Dabrowska, Maria Georghiou, Sally Humphreys, Christiane Kubitzek, Colin Baird, Keith Hodgson, Foo Irwin, Susan Midgley, Elizabeth Steel, Ong Suying, Simon Davies, Andy Gibson, Thomas Smith

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

276 Scopus citations

Abstract

Background: Results from retrospective studies suggest that use of neuromuscular blocking agents during general anaesthesia might be linked to postoperative pulmonary complications. We therefore aimed to assess whether the use of neuromuscular blocking agents is associated with postoperative pulmonary complications. Methods: We did a multicentre, prospective observational cohort study. Patients were recruited from 211 hospitals in 28 European countries. We included patients (aged ≥18 years) who received general anaesthesia for any in-hospital procedure except cardiac surgery. Patient characteristics, surgical and anaesthetic details, and chart review at discharge were prospectively collected over 2 weeks. Additionally, each patient underwent postoperative physical examination within 3 days of surgery to check for adverse pulmonary events. The study outcome was the incidence of postoperative pulmonary complications from the end of surgery up to postoperative day 28. Logistic regression analyses were adjusted for surgical factors and patients' preoperative physical status, providing adjusted odds ratios (ORadj) and adjusted absolute risk reduction (ARRadj). This study is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, number NCT01865513. Findings: Between June 16, 2014, and April 29, 2015, data from 22 803 patients were collected. The use of neuromuscular blocking agents was associated with an increased incidence of postoperative pulmonary complications in patients who had undergone general anaesthesia (1658 [7·6%] of 21 694); ORadj 1·86, 95% CI 1·53–2·26; ARRadj −4·4%, 95% CI −5·5 to −3·2). Only 2·3% of high-risk surgical patients and those with adverse respiratory profiles were anaesthetised without neuromuscular blocking agents. The use of neuromuscular monitoring (ORadj 1·31, 95% CI 1·15–1·49; ARRadj −2·6%, 95% CI −3·9 to −1·4) and the administration of reversal agents (1·23, 1·07–1·41; −1·9%, −3·2 to −0·7) were not associated with a decreased risk of postoperative pulmonary complications. Neither the choice of sugammadex instead of neostigmine for reversal (ORadj 1·03, 95% CI 0·85–1·25; ARRadj −0·3%, 95% CI −2·4 to 1·5) nor extubation at a train-of-four ratio of 0·9 or more (1·03, 0·82–1·31; −0·4%, −3·5 to 2·2) was associated with better pulmonary outcomes. Interpretation: We showed that the use of neuromuscular blocking drugs in general anaesthesia is associated with an increased risk of postoperative pulmonary complications. Anaesthetists must balance the potential benefits of neuromuscular blockade against the increased risk of postoperative pulmonary complications. Funding: European Society of Anaesthesiology.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)129-140
Number of pages12
JournalThe Lancet Respiratory Medicine
Volume7
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 2019
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Post-anaesthesia pulmonary complications after use of muscle relaxants (POPULAR): A multicentre, prospective observational study'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this