Neurocognitive Safety of Endoscopic Colloid Cyst Resection: Paired Pre- and Post-Operative Cognitive Function from an Exploratory Cohort

Objective: Resection of colloid cysts, a rare third ventricle pathology, is accepted clinical practice. Owing to their location proximal to deep gray nuclei and forniceal columns, colloid cysts have been theorized to contribute to cognitive decline. Comprehensive pre- and post-operative cognitive testing, however, has rarely been implemented. Methods: We analyzed formal neuropsychological testing performed in 20 patients undergoing endoscopic cyst resection. Pre- and post-operative performance was compared either for each individual patient or according to aggregated neuropsychological factor scores grouped via expert census. A change in performance was deemed significant if (i) it reached statistical significance and (ii) was greater than 1.5 pre-operative standard deviations. Results: Twenty patients with colloid cysts (average diameter 13.3 ± 1.3 mm) underwent matched pre- and post-operative testing. No patient had a significant change in cognitive performance. Neurocognitive metrics assessing cognitive functions typically subsumed by the temporal (p = 0.35), extratemporal (p = 0.20), occipitoparietal (p = 0.31), or frontal lobes (p = 0.11) did not change post-operatively. Similarly, no differences emerged when factor scores were generated according to composite scores of different neurocognitive domains: attention (p = 0.32), executive function (p = 0.14), language (p = 0.98), and visuospatial function (p = 0.42). Conclusions: Neuropsychological testing allows for the careful monitoring of cognitive status before and after surgery and for the identification of patients who may benefit from pre- and post-operative cognitive rehabilitation. It should also be used as a valuable surgical psychometric marker and adjuvant. No significant cognitive decline was observed in this cohort.